Concrete vs Clay Roof Tiles: A Simple Comparison

Which Tile Is Right for Your Newmarket Home?

If you are replacing a roof or planning a new roof on a property in Newmarket or the surrounding villages, one of the first decisions you will face is whether to go with concrete or clay tiles. Both are widely used across Suffolk and Cambridgeshire, and both can last decades when fitted correctly. The differences come down to cost, weight, appearance and how well each tile suits the local conditions.

Newmarket sits in an area of mostly inland, continental-influenced climate - cold winters, relatively low rainfall compared to much of the UK, and dry summers that can bake roof surfaces hard. That climate shapes which tile performs best over the long term.

Concrete Tiles: Practical and Affordable

Concrete tiles are manufactured from sand, cement and water, pressed into shape and coloured with a surface pigment. They are the most common choice on housing built from the 1960s onwards across estates in Newmarket, Bury St Edmunds and Ely.

• Cost: Concrete tiles typically cost £30-£60 per square metre supplied and fitted, making them one of the more budget-friendly pitched roofing options.
• Weight: They are heavier than clay, usually around 40-50 kg per square metre. Older properties with lighter roof structures may need checks before fitting.
• Colour fade: The surface pigment on concrete tiles does fade over time - usually visibly so after 15-20 years. Some homeowners re-coat them; others simply accept the weathered look.
• Lifespan: A quality concrete tile installation, using a breathable underlay and correctly fixed battens, can last 30-50 years before replacement is needed.
• Availability: Concrete tiles are stocked widely, which keeps repair costs down if individual tiles crack or slip.

One practical point: concrete tiles absorb more moisture than clay, which can lead to minor surface moss and algae growth, particularly on north-facing roof slopes. In Newmarket's drier climate this is less of a problem than in wetter regions, but a moss treatment every few years is still sensible maintenance.

Clay Tiles: Traditional Look and Long Life

Clay tiles are fired at high temperature, making them denser and less porous than concrete. They are the traditional choice for older Suffolk and Cambridgeshire properties - you see them regularly on Victorian and Edwardian terraces in Newmarket town centre, and on farmhouses across villages like Mildenhall and Burwell.

• Cost: Clay tiles cost more upfront - typically £60-£100 per square metre supplied and fitted, depending on the profile and source.
• Weight: Most plain clay tiles weigh 35-45 kg per square metre, similar to or slightly lighter than concrete, so structural concerns are comparable.
• Colour stability: Because clay is fired rather than pigmented, the colour is inherent in the material. It does not fade in the same way concrete does. A clay tile roof laid today should look much the same in 30 years.
• Lifespan: Clay tiles regularly outlast concrete. Well-maintained clay roofs can remain sound for 60-100 years, though the underlay and battens beneath will still need replacing on a standard 30-50 year cycle.
• Character: For period homes, clay tiles are often far more sympathetic to the original character of the building. Local planning guidance in Conservation Areas often requires a like-for-like replacement, meaning clay must stay clay.

If your home is in one of Newmarket's Conservation Areas or is a listed building, always check with the local authority before choosing a different tile type. Planning permission rules in England and Wales cover changes to roof materials on designated properties.

Planning and Conservation Considerations

Most standard roof replacements in Newmarket fall under permitted development and do not require planning permission, provided you are using a material of similar appearance to what was there before. Swapping clay for concrete on a Victorian semi in a Conservation Area could require consent. When in doubt, we advise checking with West Suffolk Council before any work starts.

The National Federation of Roofing Contractors publishes guidance on material specifications and best practice that is worth reading if you want a deeper technical understanding of pitched roofing.

Which Should You Choose?

For most modern homes in Newmarket built after 1960, concrete tiles offer good value and are perfectly suited to the local climate. For older properties, character homes or anyone wanting the longest possible service life from their roof covering, clay is the better investment despite the higher upfront cost.

If you are unsure, the pitch of your roof matters too. Very low-pitched roofs below around 15 degrees are generally not suited to either standard tile type - that is when flat roofing materials or specialist low-pitch products come into consideration. We cover all of this during a roof survey.

The honest answer is that neither tile is universally better. The right choice depends on your property type, your budget and how long you plan to stay in the home.

Get Advice From a Local Roofer

We work on roofs across Newmarket and the surrounding area every week, from Soham to Haverhill, and we can tell you exactly which tile suits your property after a quick look. If you need roof repairs to an existing tiled roof or are planning a full replacement, call us for a free local roof survey and no-obligation quote. Get in touch here and we will arrange a visit at a time that suits you.

More advice